Family Attorney
Court lets stand lesbian’s rights as parent
|
|
A landmark state Supreme Court ruling that a Seattle woman can seek parental rights to a girl she helped raise with her lesbian partner will stand now that the nation’s highest court won’t intervene. On Monday, the U.S. Supreme Court declined to consider the case of Mian Carvin and Page Britain, who conceived a child through artificial insemination and later separated. The case created a new way that people can be considered parents in Washington when state justices ruled last November that Carvin could try to prove she was a “de facto” parent to the child. Carvin and attorneys at the Northwest Women’s Law Center, who argued her case, were pleased people in her situation won’t automatically be shut out of the children’s lives. “Family law issues are generally left to the province of the states,” said Nancy Sapiro, an attorney at the law center. “It’s not surprising that the U.S. Supreme Court recognized that.” She said the issue was not simply about gay rights but a broader effort “to make our state family laws relevant to the way families look today.” Carvin was thrilled the court let the state ruling stand, she said through her lawyers. But Britain’s attorneys said Britain and all other fit, biological parents should be able to decide who should be a part of their children’s lives. They argued that the Washington ruling opened the door for all kinds of people – from live-in boyfriends to roommates – to claim parental rights. “Under the court’s ruling, a child could have an unlimited number of parents,” said Britain’s Seattle attorney, Kristen Waggoner. She said judges in more than 30 states have reached inconsistent conclusions on the issue. “I think it’s inevitable the Supreme Court is going to take one of these cases,” said Jordan Lorence, who represented Britain for the Alliance Defense Fund. “There is nothing that says family law is exempt from federal constitutional scrutiny.” Carvin and Britain were in a long-term relationship when they decided in 1994 to have Britain artificially inseminated. They agreed that Britain would work while Carvin stayed home to care for the little girl. The women broke up when the girl was 6, and Britain no longer wanted Carvin to be a part of the child’s life. Britain ended up marrying the sperm donor, a man identified in court documents as a gay friend now teaching in Thailand. Source : seattlepi.nwsource.com |
Related Articles from Attorney for Family
Transcript: The Republican Debate
STEPHANOPOULOS: Our goal today is to get a real debate going among all of you, to find out where you stand on the issues, but also to figure out the real differences that separate you. And in that spirit, here in Iowa you've already been going at each other, somewhat beneath the radar screen, on the issue of abortion. Senator Brownback, your campaign has been making phone calls to Iowa voters about Mitt Romney, and I want to show it for our viewers. It's called an urgent action alert. (BEGIN AUDIO CLIP) ANNOUNCER: Mitt Romney is telling Iowans that he is
Have your say: Family law reforms
Ministers said that they had put children at the centre of the proposals, which include more access to mediation for couples splitting up. Unmarried fathers who are registered on a birth certificate will be given parental rights and responsibilities. There are also plans to allow couples to get divorced quicker, but there are no legal access rights for grandparents. We asked what you think of the bill - here are your emails. Reform is needed to reflect the changing shape of society. However, why are there always bills to support families, or single parents. It seems this country is far
Have your say: Family law reforms
Ministers said that they had put children at the centre of the proposals, which include more access to mediation for couples splitting up. Unmarried fathers who are registered on a birth certificate will be given parental rights and responsibilities. There are also plans to allow couples to get divorced quicker, but there are no legal access rights for grandparents. We asked what you think of the bill - here are your emails. Reform is needed to reflect the changing shape of society. However, why are there always bills to support families, or single parents. It seems this country is far
Canada Rules ’Spouse’ Includes Homosexuals
The Supreme Court of Canada, in one of the most far-reaching homosexual-rights rulings anywhere, today struck down a heterosexual definition of the word ''spouse.'' In an 8-to-1 decision, the court ruled that Ontario's Family Law Act was unconstitutional in denying homosexuals the right to apply for alimony from each other. ''The Supreme Court has overturned centuries of social tradition,'' said Darrel Reid, president of Focus on the Family Canada, which intervened in the case to argue against expanding gay rights. The case involved two lesbians, identified only as M and H. Denied spousal support after separating from her partner, M
Behind Baldwin’s Tirade
Sometimes explosions can reveal as much as they destroy. While Alec Baldwin's shockingly abusive tirade against his 11-year-old daughter may have devasted her and ruined his chances in his bitter custody fight with ex-wife Kim Basinger, it illuminates a common but very controversial issue in family law: parental alienation. In a statement issued today, Baldwin himself put it front and center. He said he was "sorry for losing my temper with my child" but claims that he has "been driven to the edge by parental alienation for many years now." According to the Parental Alienation Awareness Organization website, this is any